The Hilliard Planning & Zoning Commission on Nov. 13 approved a final development plan for Smoke Lick Barbecue at 4333 Cosgrove Road but voted down a request to keep multiple awning signs.

Staff planner Seth told commissioners the smoker and associated wood pile have been on site for some time but must be brought into compliance with the National Electric Code; staff recommended approval of the final development plan provided the owner obtains an electrical permit, encloses the wood pile with stanchions to reduce dislodgement, and prohibits parking in the drive‑through area to protect emergency access (a Norwich Township Fire Department request).

In contrast, staff recommended disapproval of the graphic/sign variance, noting the awning signage and additional pig logos conflict with the Hoffman Farms PUD concept and exceed the sign code’s intent for harmonious, non‑excessive signage. Commissioners discussed alternatives — including removing the existing wall graphic if the commission allowed the awning — and asked staff whether vehicles parked behind the building were tenant‑specific (staff said they could not determine that).

A motion to approve the final development plan passed on a 6–1 roll call (Yes: Moog, Papsidero, Italiano, Saunders, Marsh, Schneck; No: Martin). A subsequent motion to grant the sign variance failed 6–1 (Yes: Moog; No: Schneck, Italiano, Martin, Saunders, Papsidero, Marsh). The record shows one nearby resident, James Wiseman, spoke during public comment to confirm notice receipt and ask about potential future zoning changes affecting adjacent woods.

The approval requires the applicant to obtain the necessary electrical permit and meet all National Electric Code requirements before final sign‑off. The commission’s denial of the sign variance means the applicant must either remove the awning signage or rework it to conform to the PUD and city sign code if they wish to retain awning elements.

Staff said there were no outstanding complaints about the smoker’s visibility from neighboring residences but emphasized compliance is required for continued operation.