Mister Lodge Seeks Variance for New Garage on Rainbow Street Property

During the St. Croix County Board of Adjustment meeting on August 28, 2025, a significant discussion centered around a variance request from local resident Mr. Lodge, who aims to construct a new detached garage on his property located on Rainbow Street. This request is particularly noteworthy due to the unique challenges posed by the property’s nonconforming status and its proximity to a former highway right-of-way.

Mr. Lodge's proposal involves replacing an existing garage that straddles the property line of the right-of-way, which has complicated the property’s layout. The new structure is planned to be 30 by 50 feet and will be positioned behind the dwelling, ensuring it does not visually impact the nearby riverway. The property is situated 50 feet from the ordinary high watermark, and the proposed garage will not encroach on the required 40-foot setback from the top of the slope.

The discussion highlighted the broader implications of the variance, as it would allow Mr. Lodge to correct the placement of nonconforming structures on his property. The existing garage was found to be over the property line during a survey in 2017, a situation exacerbated by the construction of State Highway 64, which removed over 40% of Lot 6 due to the DOT easement.

In addition to addressing the structural concerns, Mr. Lodge has proposed stormwater mitigation measures, including gutters and a rain garden, to manage runoff and prevent erosion. These measures will be subject to administrative review through a follow-up land use permit.

The meeting underscored the complexities of property management in areas affected by historical infrastructure changes and the importance of ensuring compliance with local regulations while accommodating residents' needs. The board's decision on this variance will not only impact Mr. Lodge's property but also set a precedent for similar cases in the community, reflecting the ongoing challenges of balancing development with environmental stewardship.