The Boulder Landmarks Board convened on August 8, 2025, to discuss a significant demolition application for a historic home located at 2747 Fourth Street. The meeting highlighted the delicate balance between preserving Boulder’s historic character and addressing the practical needs of property owners.

During the meeting, staff presented findings indicating that the building is in poor condition, with rehabilitation costs estimated between $200,000 and $700,000. Factors contributing to its deteriorated state include age, expansive soils, and structural issues exacerbated by previous excavation. Staff concluded that the costs associated with restoring the building are unreasonable, recommending approval for its demolition based on these assessments.

Jacqueline Wade, the homeowner, addressed the board, emphasizing her family's struggles with the house's condition. She noted that despite her efforts to maintain the property since purchasing it in 2011, serious issues such as a collapsed foundation and lack of running water rendered it uninhabitable. Wade argued that the preservation of historic buildings should not come at the expense of safety and dignity for families like hers, who face unique challenges.

Wade's appeal underscored the need for a more inclusive approach to historic preservation, advocating for a balance that considers both public heritage and the private realities of homeowners. She expressed a desire to replace the existing structure with a modern, multi-generational home to better accommodate her medically fragile son.

The discussions at the meeting reflect broader themes in Boulder regarding housing stability, community diversity, and the challenges of maintaining historic properties in a rapidly changing environment. As the board deliberates on the application, the outcome could set a precedent for future cases where historic preservation intersects with the pressing needs of residents. The decision will be closely watched by both preservation advocates and those concerned about housing accessibility in Boulder.