Maui County Council members faced pressing concerns during a public hearing on August 13, 2025, as residents voiced their strong opposition to proposed housing developments in South Maui. The discussions centered around the potential addition of 6,000 housing units, which many community members believe could exacerbate existing issues rather than provide solutions.

One resident highlighted the critical housing crisis in Maui, warning that without adequate housing, businesses could suffer due to a lack of employees. This sentiment was echoed by others who expressed frustration over the density of South Maui and the need for careful consideration of future developments. The resident urged the council to reconsider the project, emphasizing the importance of maintaining a balance between growth and community needs.

Concerns about infrastructure were also prominent, particularly regarding evacuation routes in light of recent natural disasters. A resident recounted a frightening tsunami exercise that revealed the inadequacy of current escape routes from South Maui, stressing the need for improved planning and infrastructure before any new housing projects are approved. They called for the council to ensure that necessary road expansions, such as the Imani Highway, are funded by developers to prevent worsening traffic conditions.

Jordan Ruidas, representing Lahaina Strong, further criticized the proposed amendments to housing bills 171 and 172, which would reduce the number of affordable housing units promised to the community. Ruidas pointed out that the original agreement included 700 units, but the current proposal would cut that number significantly, shifting the burden of infrastructure costs from developers to taxpayers. He urged the council to hold developers accountable for their commitments and to prioritize the community's need for affordable housing.

The meeting underscored the urgency of addressing housing and infrastructure challenges in Maui County. As residents prepare for potential ballot measures in 2026, the council's decisions in the coming months will be crucial in shaping the future of housing and community safety in South Maui. The call for transparency and accountability from developers reflects a growing demand for responsible growth that aligns with the needs of the community.