The McKinney Historic Preservation Advisory Board convened on August 7, 2025, to discuss significant proposed changes to a historic property identified in the 2023 historic resources survey as a medium priority home. The meeting focused on the implications of these changes for the property's historical integrity.

The property in question features a pier in the Beam Foundation and has been noted for its contribution to local history, despite alterations that have diminished its integrity. The proposed modifications include the addition of large dormers and alterations to the roofline, which were presented through visual aids comparing current and proposed elevations of the structure.

Staff recommendations emphasized the need for a certificate of appropriateness, suggesting approval with conditions. Specifically, they advised the removal of two proposed shed dormers, citing concerns that the changes would violate several standards set by the Secretary of the Interior for rehabilitation. These standards stress the importance of retaining the historic character of properties and ensuring that new additions do not compromise their integrity.

The board was presented with four options regarding the proposal: to approve, approve with conditions, deny, or issue a request for further presentation from the property owners. The discussion highlighted the balance between modernization and preservation, with staff expressing that the proposed alterations could significantly impact the historic nature of the property.

As the meeting progressed, community members were invited to voice their opinions, indicating a commitment to public engagement in the preservation process. The board's decision will play a crucial role in determining the future of this historic site and its contribution to McKinney's architectural heritage.