The San Antonio Historic and Design Review Commission convened on August 6, 2025, to discuss a proposed development project that has raised significant concerns among local residents. The meeting focused on the design and potential impact of a new structure near the River Walk, with particular attention to its size, noise, and rainwater management.

Commissioners expressed apprehension regarding the building's massing and its overwhelming presence in the historic area. One commissioner noted that while the design was airy, it might not be suitable for the neighborhood, emphasizing the need for a balance between development and preserving the area's aesthetic. Concerns were also raised about how rainwater would be managed, with suggestions that it should not be directed into the river but rather into street drainage systems.

The discussion highlighted the importance of community engagement, as several commissioners pointed out that the developers had not adequately communicated with neighboring properties, particularly the Makara establishment. This lack of dialogue was seen as a significant oversight, with calls for the developers to work closely with neighbors to address their concerns, especially regarding noise and visual impact.

In a motion to disapprove the project, several commissioners cited the need to prioritize the neighborhood's character and the potential nuisances that could arise from the new development. However, a subsequent motion to approve the project with stipulations was proposed, which included a requirement for the developers to collaborate with adjacent neighbors during the design phase to mitigate their concerns.

The commission ultimately voted on the motions, with the initial disapproval failing. The revised motion to approve the project with conditions was passed, reflecting a compromise aimed at addressing community concerns while allowing for development. The commission emphasized the importance of ongoing communication between the developers and the local community to ensure that the project aligns with the neighborhood's needs and expectations.