A proposed home addition in St. Pete Beach has been denied by the Board of Adjustment, raising concerns about neighborhood harmony and zoning regulations. James Carney, the homeowner, sought to expand his property by adding a bedroom and bathroom while relocating his garage. He emphasized the need for more space due to a growing family, stating, “I’d like to make some room” as he prepares for a grandchild.

During the meeting, Carney detailed his plans, including maintaining the existing stucco style and ensuring that the circular driveway would remain functional. However, board members expressed reservations about the significant encroachment into the front yard, with one member noting, “I didn’t see that being necessarily harmonious with the neighborhood.”

Despite Carney's assurances that he had consulted neighbors and received positive feedback, the board ultimately voted against the proposal. The motion to approve the addition failed with a vote of 3 to 1, leading to a subsequent motion to deny the application, which passed unanimously.

The board's decision underscores the ongoing challenge of balancing individual property improvements with community standards and zoning laws. As Carney reflects on his options, the denial highlights the complexities homeowners face when seeking to modify their residences in established neighborhoods.