The City of Waukesha's Board of Review convened on July 29, 2025, to address property assessment disputes, focusing on the valuation of a local dealership. The meeting highlighted significant concerns regarding the assessment process and the fairness of property valuations in the area.

The Board began by outlining the procedures for the hearing, emphasizing that the burden of proof lies with the taxpayer to demonstrate that the assessor's valuation is incorrect. Wayne Towne, representing the objector, presented a case arguing that the current assessed value of $7,445,600 for the dealership was excessively high compared to previous years and market trends. He claimed that the valuation had increased dramatically from $5,300,000 to $7,400,000 in just three years, raising questions about the rationale behind such a steep rise.

Towne criticized the county's assessment practices, suggesting that they had shifted from a conservative approach to one that disproportionately favors higher valuations. He pointed out discrepancies in the valuation per square foot, noting that the current assessment of $293.30 per square foot was significantly higher than previous assessments and market comparisons. He argued that the dealership's age and condition did not justify the inflated valuation, stating that the property, built in 1999, should not command such a high price.

The Board of Review listened to Towne's testimony and will deliberate on the evidence presented before making a determination. The outcome of this case could have broader implications for property owners in Waukesha, as it raises critical questions about the consistency and fairness of property assessments in the city. The Board's decision will be closely watched by local stakeholders, as it may influence future assessments and taxpayer confidence in the evaluation process.