Concerns over proposed multi-family housing developments dominated the recent Planning Commission meeting in Nashville, as local residents voiced strong objections to a plan that could significantly alter their neighborhood.

A resident from McClellan Street, who has lived in the area for 35 years, expressed deep worries about the potential construction of five multi-family homes on adjacent lots. The speaker highlighted the history of neglect by the current property owner, noting that the neighboring homes have been poorly maintained since their purchase in 2013. "For years, 408 has had standing water in the basement," the resident stated, emphasizing the lack of upkeep and the negative impact on the community.

The resident argued that the proposed development would lead to overcrowding, predicting that the area could see around ten families crammed into two small lots. "This gives us around 10 crowded families... becoming very slummy in less than 5 years, I guarantee you," they warned. The speaker also raised concerns about the loss of privacy and the enjoyment of their own backyard, which they hope to pass down to their grandchildren.

In a plea for a more reasonable alternative, the resident suggested that the owner consider building two duplexes instead, which would provide four rental units without overwhelming the neighborhood. "Why allow them to fill up the lots with 5 multifamily homes right next to us, 5 feet from us?" they questioned, underscoring the potential negative impact on property values and quality of life.

As the Planning Commission deliberates on this contentious proposal, the voices of concerned residents highlight the ongoing tension between development and community preservation in Nashville. The outcome of this decision could shape the future of the neighborhood for years to come.