During the recent Planning Commission meeting in Atherton, a significant discussion centered on tree preservation amid construction plans. The dialogue highlighted the delicate balance between development and environmental conservation, with one commissioner humorously noting, "If you have a choice between being a tree or a person in Atherton, be a tree. It's much safer."

Resident Karen Goodman raised concerns about the proximity of a proposed second story to a protected tree, seeking clarification on the distance from the tree's trunk. The current foundation sits approximately 7 to 7.5 feet away, while the new proposal requests a reduction to 6 feet. Goodman expressed her preference for preserving the tree, emphasizing its importance to the local ecosystem.

Commissioner Sally, who has been actively involved in tree protection efforts, supported the compromise, stating that the tree has adapted well to its environment. She reassured attendees that the developers would be required to have an arborist monitor the tree monthly, ensuring its health during construction.

The meeting concluded with a sense of satisfaction among the commissioners, as they felt the revised proposal struck a balance between development needs and environmental stewardship. The decision to prioritize tree preservation reflects Atherton's commitment to maintaining its natural landscape while accommodating growth.