The Town Council of Atherton held a Planning Council meeting on July 23, 2025, where significant discussions centered around tree preservation and modifications to a residential property. The meeting primarily focused on a proposal involving the removal and replacement of heritage trees to accommodate a new motor court and driveway design for a Georgian-style home.

The proposal included the removal of two Coast Live Oaks, which the town arborist deemed necessary due to the design's impact on the property. The arborist approved the tree removal request under specific conditions, including the use of alternative materials for the driveway and hand excavations to minimize damage to surrounding trees. The council also discussed the removal of a multi-trunk Redwood and a cedar tree, with the arborist recommending the replacement of the cedar tree but denying the removal of the Redwood.

Planning staff supported the removal of both trees, emphasizing the importance of symmetry in the design of the residence and its entrance. The staff's recommendation was based on the overall aesthetic and functional needs of the property, despite noting that design considerations are not typically a criterion for such decisions.

Public comments included insights from the project architect, who highlighted the historical significance of the property and the need for modern updates. The architect argued that the proposed changes would enhance the property's aesthetics while preserving the integrity of the heritage trees.

The council presented two motions for consideration: one supporting the staff's recommendations for tree removals and the other proposing a split decision regarding the Redwood tree. The meeting concluded with an invitation for public comments, emphasizing the importance of community input in the planning process.

Overall, the discussions underscored the balance between development needs and environmental preservation, reflecting ongoing efforts to maintain Atherton's character while accommodating modern residential requirements. The council's decisions will shape the future of the property and its integration within the community.