The San Antonio Historic Compliance and Technical Advisory Board convened on July 18, 2025, to discuss a request for a certificate of appropriateness concerning a proposed fence installation at 528 Lee Street. The applicant, Troy Najar, presented his case for a 6-foot tall wood privacy gate to be installed between two houses on the property, which he intends to use as his primary residence.

The meeting began with staff recommendations against the approval of the request, citing that a 6-foot tall privacy gate would not comply with regulations as it extends past the front wall plane of the adjacent historic structure at 530 Lee Street. Staff indicated that a fence behind the front wall plane could be administratively approved without further review.

Najar, who has recently returned to San Antonio and is committed to investing in his home, expressed his desire for a unique design that would enhance the aesthetic of the property. He emphasized that he is not renting the houses but intends to live in them, which he believes adds significance to his request. During his presentation, he acknowledged the growing trend of rentals in the area and highlighted the importance of maintaining the neighborhood's character.

Board members engaged in a detailed discussion regarding the height and placement of the proposed fence. Najar initially sought a 6-foot height for privacy but later indicated he would be open to a 4-foot option if it meant gaining approval. The board noted that a 4-foot fence would be less contentious and could be approved without further deliberation, while a 6-foot fence would require adherence to specific guidelines.

The conversation also touched on the unique configuration of the two houses on the property, with Najar arguing that the house at 528 Lee Street should be considered the front panel since it is the primary residence on the title. However, board members clarified that the application was specifically addressing the facade of 530 Lee Street, which complicated the approval process.

Ultimately, the board acknowledged the unusual circumstances of the property and the applicant's willingness to compromise. They suggested that if Najar were to place the fence directly behind the front wall plane of 530 Lee Street, he could achieve the desired height without needing further approval.

As the meeting progressed, Najar reiterated his commitment to enhancing the property while respecting the historical context of the neighborhood. The board concluded the discussion without a formal vote, indicating that further deliberation would be necessary to reach a resolution that balances the applicant's desires with compliance to historical preservation standards.