In a heated session on July 15, 2025, the Tompkins County Legislature grappled with a contentious diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) policy, reflecting deep divisions among its members. The debate centered on whether to amend existing language that some legislators deemed politically charged and divisive.

Legislator Rich John voiced strong opposition to the current wording, arguing that it has become a "hot button issue" and suggesting that it alienates potential allies. He proposed a rewrite using simpler, more inclusive language that would resonate better with constituents. "We need to meet people where they're at," he stated, emphasizing the importance of unity in addressing societal issues.

Despite John's concerns, other legislators defended the policy's language, asserting that it is essential for institutionalizing equity within county operations. Legislator Anne Corman highlighted the importance of maintaining the current language to ensure the county's commitment to diversity and inclusion. "Words have power," she asserted, underscoring the need for precise terminology in DEI efforts.

The vote on an amendment to remove controversial language resulted in a tie, ultimately leaving the original wording intact. This decision reflects the ongoing struggle within the legislature to balance local values with broader political narratives, particularly in a state that has not shifted its stance on DEI.

As the meeting concluded, the legislators acknowledged the need for continued dialogue on the policy's implications and effectiveness. The outcome signals a commitment to uphold the existing DEI framework while recognizing the challenges of navigating a politically charged landscape. The legislature's next steps will likely involve further discussions on how to enhance community engagement and ensure that the policy reflects the diverse voices of Tompkins County residents.