During the St. Augustine City Commission meeting on July 14, 2025, community members voiced significant concerns regarding public safety and animal welfare, particularly focusing on the use of horse-drawn carriages in the city.

Scott York, a local resident, began the meeting by praising city staff for their efforts in organizing a successful July 4th celebration, which included enhanced security measures such as additional restrooms and cooling areas. He highlighted the importance of these improvements for both residents and visitors, noting that many plan their vacations around this event. York emphasized the effectiveness of temporary security barriers used during the festivities, suggesting that they could be adapted for future events to improve wayfinding without appearing overly intrusive.

However, the tone shifted dramatically as Heather Wilson, a newcomer to St. Augustine, raised alarming issues regarding the treatment of horses used in carriage rides. She shared personal observations and evidence of mistreatment, including a video of a horse being struck by a carriage driver. Wilson argued that the conditions under which the horses operate pose significant health risks and violate the city’s municipal code. She called for a reevaluation of the franchise agreements that govern carriage operations, asserting that they fail to protect the animals adequately.

Brian Wilson, also addressing the commission, echoed these concerns and urged the city to consider alternatives to horse-drawn carriages. He highlighted the dangers these animals face daily in traffic and advocated for a comprehensive review of the ordinances governing their use, rather than piecemeal adjustments.

Carla Wilson added to the discussion by pointing out the increasing traffic congestion in St. Augustine, which exacerbates the risks associated with horse-drawn carriages. She referenced accidents involving such carriages, both locally and nationwide, and stressed the need for the city to prioritize safety as its population and visitor numbers continue to grow.

The meeting underscored a critical dialogue about balancing tradition with modern safety standards in St. Augustine. As the city navigates these discussions, the implications for both public safety and animal welfare remain at the forefront of community concerns. The commission's next steps will likely involve addressing these issues more thoroughly, as residents call for significant changes to ensure the well-being of both people and animals in the historic city.