During the Sedona City Council meeting on July 9, 2025, a significant discussion centered around water management strategies, particularly the evaluation of irrigation practices and the potential for new recharge wells. The council reviewed a comprehensive ranking of alternatives aimed at optimizing water use, with a focus on sustainability and cost-effectiveness.

The top-ranked option involved abandoning 200 acres of irrigation while adding recharge wells, which was identified as the most economical solution. This approach scored a perfect 10 in terms of cost, reflecting its potential to enhance water management without the need for extensive infrastructure changes. The second alternative also proposed abandoning irrigation but included delivering reclaimed water to parks and schools, while the third option suggested using reclaimed water as a potable source, despite its higher costs.

Council members expressed concerns regarding the scoring of alternatives, particularly questioning the fairness of the lowest-ranked option, which involved maintaining current irrigation practices while adding recharge wells. Some members argued that this option did not adequately consider the environmental impact and operational challenges associated with irrigation.

The discussion highlighted the complexities of water management in Sedona, including the limitations of current irrigation systems and the need for efficient use of resources. Council members noted that operational difficulties, such as freezing pipes and the risk of overfilling reservoirs, complicate irrigation efforts. They emphasized the importance of maximizing the use of existing recharge wells, which can operate continuously, to alleviate pressure on storage facilities.

As the council moves forward, the implications of these discussions are clear: Sedona is prioritizing sustainable water management practices that balance economic considerations with environmental stewardship. The decisions made in this meeting will shape the city’s approach to water use in the coming years, ensuring that resources are managed effectively for the benefit of the community.